From Chris Iggo, Chief Investment Officer, Core Investments, AXA Investment Managers.
When I started in asset management, the chief rationale for bond investing was based on the compounding of income returns. After years of price volatility and central banks’ distorting of yields, we are back to that simple mantra. Income rules right now. Of course, attention must be paid to shifting interest rate expectations, surprise policy moves, or changes in the credit environment. But higher-for-longer interest rates have benefited bonds. Older bonds approaching maturity are on a pull-to-par journey, while new bonds have higher coupons. Together this means fixed income is much more attractive.
If the US economy avoids a hard landing, equities should continue to outperform bonds. We are not in a recession. The soft landing scenario is very much priced in and for the US at least, the data suggests it might be the softest of soft landings. The recession – if there is to be one – is delayed. Interest rates might have peaked but a long plateau could be ahead of us.
Summer arrives in the North
It is noteworthy that as the northern hemisphere heads towards the summer holidays, markets are characterised by lower volatility and, for a large part, returns are dominated by income. Indeed, the ratio of carry (or income) to volatility has increased in recent months because of income returns going up – especially in fixed income markets – and volatility coming down. The situation reflects the benign nature of the macroeconomic backdrop and growing confidence in a soft-landing scenario where inflation continues to moderate without the need for a recession.
Higher coupons
In fixed income markets, income return has been slowly increasing, reflecting higher coupons in response to elevated interest rates since the monetary tightening cycle began in 2022. Looking at representative corporate credit bond indices, the average coupon on US dollar investment grade bonds has risen by 65-70 basis points (bp) since the beginning of March 2022. The equivalent increases are 100bp for the euro investment grade market; 40-50bp in sterling; and 60-100bp in US dollar and euro high yield bond markets. In the euro market today, around 25% of outstanding corporate issues have a coupon of less than 2% and 22% have a coupon that is higher than the current average yield to worst of 3.8%. In March 2020, 70% of outstanding bonds had a coupon of less than 2%. As rates remain higher for longer, the market coupon will increase and that means higher income returns for investors.
Also read: Widening Cracks In The Investment Landscape
Returns recovering after the shock of 2022
Fixed income returns are in recovery. However, 2022 was such a shock to market pricing that parts of the market are still in negative drawdown territory. The worst examples are long-duration bonds. Short-duration strategies have recovered their market value. Compare the two charts below. They show the drawdown experience of the US investment grade credit index for the one-to-three-year maturity bucket and the over 10-year bucket.
Eyes on Paris
A key risk to bond markets in the near future comes from Europe. The uncertainty over France’s budget trajectory – because of the current political situation – has already led to an increase in French government bond yields relative to German yields. Market and European institutional pressure might eventually contain the policy proposals currently being discussed in the election campaign but there is a risk of spreads widening further if markets get a sniff of a new government trying to implement tax cuts or spending increases which would lead to the French public deficit moving in the wrong direction.
A more optimistic view is that cohabitation in France after the upcoming National Assembly election will constrain the more radical proposals. The spectre of what happened to UK markets in September 2022 when then-Prime Minister Liz Truss implemented a populist Budget will have not gone unnoticed in Paris. If this is the outcome, any contagion in other European government bond markets or in credit markets might be potential buying opportunities during the summer.
Credit itself looks fine
The other risk is that we begin to enter a period of generalised credit deterioration. For some time, there has been evidence from the US of increased delinquencies in areas like revolving consumer credit and credit cards, while the issues surrounding commercial real estate are well known. There have been some distressed situations in high yield as well, but, so far, these have been idiosyncratic. However, should economic data continue to soften, and a harder landing become more evident, credit risk indicators would start to flash, with spreads on cash bonds and credit default swap indices widening.
If the carry-to-volatility relationship is very benign now, it is most likely to worsen because of higher volatility on credit spreads coming from concerns about a weaker economic outlook, the corporate earnings cycle turning softer, or policy uncertainty becoming more material. The good news is none of this is evident today. Equity markets continue to perform well – even though they are skewed by technology stocks – and demand for credit remains extremely strong. The recovery in fixed income returns looks set to continue.
(Performance data/data sources: Refinitiv DataStream, Bloomberg, as of 25 June 2024, unless otherwise stated). Past performance should not be seen as a guide to future returns.
*As at the end of March 2024, including non-consolidated entities.
** As at the end of December 2023.
